Skip to main content

Energy from rain – The Physics of Electricity Market Reform with Merit


It has been suggested in the high-rise, densely populated cities of the near future that there is the potential to generate energy from rain falling on the rooves of these tall building. It is shown from first principles, by means of a simple calculation using some basic equations in physics, that this is not an economically feasible concept. Some suggestions will be made to correct the British government’s erroneous assumptions when it comes to governing energy strategy through its Electricity Market Reform policies.
It does not seem feasible to me to produce electricity from rainfall on a city. The first thought that came to my mind when this idea was suggested is that water is generally pumped to the top of high buildings and held in storage tanks to be available for when it is needed to be used - in order to maintain satisfactory water pressure. The second thought that I had was that there would not be a significant enough amount of water falling on a building’s roof to generate more hydro energy than this standard engineering process consumes. Further thought led me to believe that there is more potential for a “pumped storage” system for energy storage using a water tank at the top of a tall building to store electricity than there is for a sustainable hydropower scheme.
Now the economics of the situation are really governed by the physics. So let us consider the equation for Gravitational Potential Energy (GPE), which is GPE = mgh (which is the mass multiplied by the effect of gravity of the water (or its weight) multiplied by the height of the building). This would then be converted into Kinetic Energy (KE) when the water drops down. So GPE = mgh = KE (= 1/2mv^2)
This kinetic energy could be used to turn a turbine with efficiency of say at least 50% given the inefficiencies such a system would have to overcome.
Now, let’s do a calculation: 50cm rain falling on 1 hectare (10,000 sq metre), and then falling a height of 1000 metres (taller than the Burj Khalifa in Dubai but in the future it could be possible), a typical high-rise city of the future, how many kWh can be generated?
So 0.5m of rain (a huge amount - more than a year's worth!)
We have the volume of rain given by area multiplied by depth of total rainfall = 0.5*10000=5000m^3, 1 m^3 water = 1 ton
GPE = mgh = 5000 ton of water * 1000 (to convert to kg) * 10 ( m/s^2, the effects of to 1 significant figure) * 1000 (m, height of the buildings) = 50 000 000 000  kg m^2/s^2 = 50 billion joules
The unit we are after is kWh (kilo watt hours).
1 watt is 1 joule per second.
So we need to divide the figure for the KE by the efficiency factor which we have already agreed and then by 1000 to convert to kW and then divide by the number of seconds in 1 hour:
50 000 000 000 / 2 (efficiency of system) / 1000 / 60 / 60 = 6944 kWh.
6944 kWh is enough electricity  to power one energy-efficient US household.

To pump water to top of the building storage tank would require more energy than this would generate, as the pumps are not as efficient as the turbines and lose energy to heat for example.
In pumped storage where water is pumped to a higher reservoir during off peak electricity prices and then during peak demand, where electricity has a higher market price, it is released through turbines into a lower reservoir turning the GPE into electricity again.  The energy efficiency of a system such as this one (for example in Dinorwig Power Station in Wales) is about 70%.
It is clear that in these cities of tomorrow with 1 hectare plots of 1 km tall buildings there would need to be sufficient care taken in regard to energy policy. There would not be enough room for hydro power to be effective, and there would be a great problem of pollution from conventional power sources. Therefore it is clear that a high density power generating option that did not pollute the environment would be needed to meet the demand safely, reliably and securely. This means nuclear power is needed in the particular situation that we have looked at in discussing this idea.
Furthermore it is clear from the things that we have considered that there needs to be some way of storing electricity for when it is needed as there clearly is fluctuation in demand. Therefore the option of pumped storage capacity would be a valuable addition to any complete energy policy strategy.
The question of pollution is a big one to contend with as most emissions in cities such as the one we have considered come from the exhaust emissions of combustion engines in cars. This can be curtailed by simply switching to a hydrogen-powered fuel economy for transport, with hydrogen produced from renewable and nuclear power and stored in tanks at filling stations until it is needed. This option is about 30% efficient but it would allow for greater utility in the transport sector.


William Gaskell is an Old Etonian Physicist. Educated at Eton College, Windsor, he now holds a Bachelor of Science (honours) degree in Physics from Bristol University, and a Master of Science degree in Physics and Technology of Nuclear Reactors with Merit from the University of Birmingham. He has developed a special interest in all aspects of nuclear power, energy generation and infrastructure and aspires to following his father and grandfather to Trinity College, Cambridge to undertake a PhD qualification in the physics, economics and policy of his interests.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

LETTERS TO BEN: National Careers Service

Dear Ben,

Please find forwarded below the helpful advice I received from the National Careers Service RE compensation, which mirrored the advice Sue and Shirley offered after our meeting today. I hope I am communicating with you clearly enough that I want more money and more satisfaction from life, I want jobs to be easier and the girls to be easier as I currently feel frustrated. I don't feel I should have to do any more work to get it other than to raise this complaint at this point.
The thing I am most looking forward to is the rugby world cup in 2019 in Japan which I plan to go to with friends.
Regards,
William
Thanks. In reply to your email, the following information might be helpful to you.  
Your CV and cover letter look fine and you have some good work experience. Have you been keeping an eye on Hinkley point (near Bridgewater)? Here in the South West that is probably the biggest ongoing potential nuclear project at the moment and you could send a speculative CV to EDF energ…

Camden Crescent and Hedgemead Park

Here are my thoughts: Did you know that Camden Crescent, originally Camden Place and Upper Camden Place (which is now round the corner) was named after the Earl of Camden, Charles Pratt, who was Chancellor of the Exchequer so sponsored the scheme with his symbol on every door and crest of the exchequer on the decoration at the centre of the crescent? Charles Pratt was actually lord of Camden Place in Chislehurst in Kent. He was mates with William Pitt the Elder from Eton and Cambridge days. It was built 1788-1792 by John Eveleigh the architect.  One third of the 22 house crescent collapsed during a landslip which claimed 136 houses on the slopes of Lansdown Hill leading to the creation of Hedgemead Park below Camden Crescent. John Eveleigh was notoriously bankrupted in Bath, being called to the coffee shop in the Bath Chronicle by his creditors. Earl Camden was famous for supporting Fox’s Libel Act of 1792 which said that libel should be tried as murder with a jury regarding the poin…

Notes from Energy & Utility Forum 2017

1.Robert Symons, CEO of Western Power Distribution said: “Energy demand could rise by 100% by 2030. Smart grids will be needed to manage electric vehicle charging so that the usage does not exceed the supply capacity at any time during the day.”
2.Spoke to Harry Vickers, Business Development Manager of Camborne Energy Storage, Camborne Capital at the Energy and Utility Forum in London on October 23rd 2017. He told me his company is working with Elon Musk to bring Tesla battery grid storage solutions to the UK.
3.Spoke to Sally Barrett-Williams, Chairman of Energy and Utility Forum on October 23rd, who said subsidies for solar projects had ended and her company’s focus has shifted to energy storage schemes.
4.Spoke to Simon Dowland, PhD, at 13:00 on Sunday 29th October, Simon is now working up in Cambridge at the Cavendish Physics Laboratory at the University of Cambridge, he is working in industry for the company Eight19 Ltd a spin off from a research project to bring new technology …